Ensure FMLA leave doesn’t affect evaluations — Business Management Daily: Free Reports on Human Resources, Employment Law, Office Management, Office Communication, Office Technology and Small Business Tax Business Management Daily

Ensure FMLA leave doesn’t affect evaluations

Get PDF file

by on
in FMLA Guidelines,Human Resources,Leaders & Managers,Performance Reviews

When employees lose their jobs, they often look for a reason to sue. After all, they have little to lose.

One common tactic is to argue that a layoff was used as an excuse to get rid of “unproductive” employees, especially those who take advantage of their right to FMLA leave.

That’s why HR must develop a performance-appraisal system that documents that having taken FMLA leave wasn’t a factor when you evaluated employees’ work. That may require adjusting yearly goals, sales quotas and task-completion rates based on the time lost to FMLA leave.

The objective is to create a clear paper trail showing that you took care to make sure no one considered FMLA leave as a negative perform­ance factor.

It helps to work with the employee at evaluation time so you can jointly arrive at a fair evaluation that doesn’t penalize the employee for taking leave.

Recent case: Thomas Palmer worked for Harvey Gerstman Asso­ciates. When he underwent quad­ruple bypass surgery, he was out on FMLA leave for about two months. He returned with no restrictions except a temporary ban on more than six hours of work per day.

At evaluation time, Palmer’s supervisor wanted to use a recent audit of a store Palmer had managed as a negative factor. When Palmer pointed out that the audit unfairly covered events that happened when he was off work, his supervisor reconsidered. The audit was not used. Still, Palmer scored a 3.0 for the year.

Palmer lost his job in a layoff based on his score and a co-worker’s score of 4.0. He sued, alleging retaliation.

But the court tossed out the case. It reasoned that the company hadn’t used FMLA leave as a negative factor at all. (Palmer v. Harvey Gerstman Associates, No. 1:09-CV-01883, MD PA, 2011)

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: