It’s easier for employees to prove retaliation for complaining about discrimination than it is to prove the underlying complaint. When disciplining someone who has complained, make sure each infraction is iron-clad—and don’t pile on additional dubious charges.
Recent case: Evelyn, a nurse of Nigerian origin, complained about race discrimination. Soon after, she was disciplined and eventually fired for a long list of alleged wrongdoing.
She sued, arguing that about half the reasons were not factually valid.
Even so, the court dismissed her discrimination claim. But it said her retaliation claim could go forward because the false discharge reasons made her firing look like punishment. (Oseghale v. Department of Corrections, No. F068768, Court of Appeal of California, 2015)
- How to Fire an Employee the Legal Way: 6 Termination Guidelines
- Is a Policy Still a Policy if It's Not in Writing?
- Quest for 'new blood' could bleed bank account if it results in huge punitive damages award
- Madison Square Garden suit hinges on alleged background check bias
- Minimizing the legal risks of workplace romance