The New York City Transit Authority required employees over age 40 to undergo an electrocardiogram (EKG) to be considered for the job of station supervisor.
Jack Epter, 46, passed the written exam but refused to take the EKG. Instead, he filed an age discrimination claim, and won. (Epter v. New York City Transit Authority, No. 99-CV-3050, E.D.N.Y., 2001)
Advice: The golden rules in administering medical tests, as with almost every employment practice, are consistency, universal application and business necessity. By singling out a particular class of employees, you're practically begging to be sued.
Under federal law, you can require medical exams for current employees only if the tests are job-related and necessary. For a medical exam to be "job related," you must believe, based on objective evidence, that the worker's ability to do the essential job functions will be impaired or that his medical condition will pose a direct threat to others.
- How to Fire an Employee the Legal Way: 6 Termination Guidelines
- PHRA and Title VII: No delays allowed when investigating sexual harassment
- When employees foul up, feel free to tailor your response to fit the circumstances
- Is our affirmative action plan a Catch-22?
- Track declining productivity to justify staffing, pay and promotion decisions