When it comes to litigation, employers that keep meticulous performance records and can pinpoint exactly when they made important employment decisions typically fare better than those who keep sloppy records.
Recent case: Diane, who worked for a bank, suffered from frequent migraine headaches, which required her to take regular time off. She was grantedon an as-needed basis and never had any trouble using that leave.
She received athat mentioned she had some productivity problems over the past year. However, it said the employer expected the next year to go better.
Shortly after that review, she took a migraine day. The following day, the bank terminated her.
She sued, alleging that she had been terminated because of her disability and because she took.
But the bank had carefully dated notes that showed she had really been fired for violating a workplace rule against making loans for her personal benefit. She had apparently approved a loan for her sister that she subsequently used to pay her own mortgage. When the loan became delinquent, a supervisor asked Diane to get her sister to make payments loan. Diane paid the loan in full from her own account.
That triggered an HR investigation, which established a timeline. Diane had approved the loan for her sister sometime before she received her evaluation—and before she took her. The loan violated bank rules and led directly to her discharge.
The court dismissed Diane’s lawsuit, pointing out that the evaluation showed that the bank had originally planned to retain Diane despite her absences. (Justice v. Renasant Bank, 5th Cir., 2017)
Final note: Make sure you time stamp or date every document. That includes, investigation start and end dates and final decisions.
- How to Fire an Employee the Legal Way: 6 Termination Guidelines
- What should we do? We may need to terminate one of our founding partners
- Don't think 'Contractor' status shields you from retaliation
- Put reasonable limits on who can take complaints
- Consider ADA--not just the FMLA--when employee experiences difficult pregnancy