Cost of misguided English-only rule: $50,000 - Business Management Daily
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Google+

Cost of misguided English-only rule: $50,000

Get PDF file

by on
in Centerpiece,Employment Law,HR Management,Human Resources

Language policiesA New York state restaurant owner will pay $50,000 to resolve charges he discriminated against Spanish-speaking employees. In addition to subjecting workers at Antonella’s Restaurant & Pizzeria to ethnic slurs and harassment, he required them to speak only English at work.

Most “English-only” policies violate Title VII of the Civil Rights Act.

They are not strictly unlawful, but courts and the EEOC have regularly ruled that employers must be able to demonstrate a legitimate business reason for having such a policy. For example, an English-only rule might be justified when employees must engage in highly technical communications or when they work with such hazardous materials that safety requires using a common language.

However, pizza-making is not brain surgery and pizza ovens aren’t nuclear reactors.

If you are considering an English-only policy, be prepared to spell out exactly why it is necessary. If employees complain about the policy, you will want to have a written copy available to detail the rationale. If push comes to shove, the EEOC will want to see it too.

In most cases, though, a language policy is not necessary.

Employees need enough English fluency to communicate with English-only speakers (such as their supervisors) about work-related topics. Otherwise, there is rarely a good reason to forbid employees from conversing in their native language.

This case reveals an all-too-common scenario in which an English-only policy is not about workplace efficiency, but probably about bias instead. Even if the employer does not consider a language policy discriminatory, employees probably do.

That is the EEOC’s default position as well—and any evidence of name-calling, harassment, unequal pay or benefits will be viewed through that lens.

Advice: If you have an English-only policy, you better have a written justification for it. Have your attorney sign off on it. Otherwise, scrap it.

Leave a Comment