Sometimes, there are several ways to accommodate a disabled employee. As long as the one the employer chooses is reasonable, the employee can’t claim an ADA violation.
Recent case: Elisa, a police officer, was allegedly sexually harassed and developed post-traumatic stress disorder. She was transferred to a monitoring unit, but got into an argument with a co-worker and was moved back to patrol duty.
She claimed she couldn’t serve as a patrol officer because of her medications and requested monitoring duty as a reasonable accommodation. Instead, the police department offeredand other unpaid leave. She took FMLA and one additional leave, but refused a second leave.
She was discharged and sued, alleging failure to accommodate. The court said she had been accommodated with leave; her preference didn’t trump the department’s accommodation choice. (Diaz v. City of Philadelphia, No. 12-2593, 3rd Cir., 2014)