Survive most lawsuits by being able to cite solid, documented reasons for termination — Business Management Daily: Free Reports on Human Resources, Employment Law, Office Management, Office Communication, Office Technology and Small Business Tax Business Management Daily
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Google+

Survive most lawsuits by being able to cite solid, documented reasons for termination

Get PDF file

by on
in Firing,Human Resources

Employers that routinely discipline employees only for solid, business-related reasons seldom find themselves on the losing side of a discrimination or retaliation lawsuit.

Courts like to see that ­employers pause before firing an employee accused of breaking a rule and then document their investigation carefully.

Interviewing the employee should be routine in most disciplinary cases. Temporarily suspending an employee before making a final decision also shows the court that the process was fair.

Recent case: Bernadette worked as an assistant manager for a nonprofit social service agency that provides services to those in need in the community, including the developmentally disabled, children at risk and the elderly.

Her job included tracking her ­subordinates’ hours and making sure they were paid.

Bernadette took FMLA leave and then returned to work. Soon, two employees complained to Berna­dette’s supervisor that they hadn’t been paid. The agency launched an investigation and interviewed Ber­nadette, who admitted she hadn’t handed in the time sheets in question. How­­ever, she said everyone else had been properly paid. That turned out to be untrue. Plus, an employee said Bernadette had made her alter her time sheets to show fewer hours worked. Berna­dette was fired.

She fired back with an FMLA retaliation lawsuit, but didn’t get far.

It was clear to the court that the agency had good, solid and documented reasons to fire her unrelated to her FMLA leave. (Guidry v. Gulf Coast Teaching, No. 13-30540, 5th Cir., 2014)

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: