Quiz for managers: Documenting performance — Business Management Daily: Free Reports on Human Resources, Employment Law, Office Management, Office Communication, Office Technology and Small Business Tax Business Management Daily
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Google+

Quiz for managers: Documenting performance

Get PDF file

by on
in Leaders & Managers,Performance Reviews

Documentation quiz for managers

It’s important to know the kind of language managers should—and should not—use in documentation. Test your knowl­edge by answering “True” or “False” to the following statements:

_____ 1. An employee is caught stealing company equipment. It’s best to list the termination reason as “gross misconduct” since “stealing” could be defamatory.

_____ 2. An employee with a disability is having trouble meeting job standards. It’s better to list her performance as “satisfactory” so she doesn’t become discouraged.

_____ 3. A disciplinary warning should always contain language that spells out the potential penalties the employee faces if he repeats the offense.

_____ 4. If an employee is terminated for poor performance, the best way to disqualify him from unemployment benefits is to use terms such as “unsatisfactory work” or “totally inefficient.”

Performance reviews are a legal minefield, and laws and benchmarks change constantly. Protect your organization – and yourself. Order your copy of The Manager’s Guide to Effective, Legal Performance Reviews today.


1. FALSE. It’s not defamatory to list the truthful reason for an employee’s termination and to share that on a need-to-know basis. Sharing the reason with other employees or the public could be defamatory.

2. FALSE. This type of thinking can land a man­ager in the middle of a disability discrimination lawsuit if the employee has to be fired and then fights your performance reasoning in court. So be honest. Spell out the problems and attempt to find solutions.

3. TRUE. Courts typically uphold claims if they believe an employee was not properly warned about the possible consequences of future violations. So spell out in writing exactly what the em­­ployee can expect from further violations.

4. FALSE. Terms such as “unsatisfactory work” are the very ones that could result in unemployment benefits. Such payments are typically withheld only when employees are terminated for gross insubordination or willful misconduct.

There are so many documentation mistakes that put you at risk. The Manager's Guide to Effective, Legal Performance Reviews is your documentation guidebook. Get this step-by-step guide on everything from writing the job description to establishing clear benchmarks to documenting performance to communicating effectively. Order your copy here.

To be successful, employee feedback should not be an annual or even quar­­terly event. It should be a routine part of a manager’s day.

In the same way, managers should make documentation of employee performance, behavior and discipline a regular habit.

This documentation can be informal as handwritten notes tossed in an employee’s file, but they should always include the dates and names of all parties involved. As with any documentation, stick to the facts and stay objective. Avoid opinions.

A manager’s documentation should be built on three basic principles:

1. Immediate. Memory is a shaky defense in court, so make sure to take notes right after an incident occurs. That makes it much harder for an employee to cast doubt on a manager’s motives if the written explanation comes right after the action.

2. Accurate & believable. When an outside observer (judge, jury or EEO investigator) is called to judge your side of the story, detailed observations add authenticity. The more specific the documentation, the greater the credibility. Hang your hat on facts, not impressions, to reflect objectivity.

For example, instead of noting that “Bill’s work has been sloppy lately,” it’s better to note, “In each of his last three reports, Bill had at least two im­­portant accounting mistakes that needed revisions.”

3. Agreement. If both sides agree on what happened, it’s much tougher for either side to later change claims. Try to get employees in­­volved in the documentation process.

Finally! Painless Performance Reviews …

If you’ve ever “umm’d and ahh’d” your way through an employee’s performance review, you know how painful and unproductive that can be. But now, you can conduct a flawless performance review with ease.

All you need is the strategies and techniques you’ll find in The Manager’s Guide to Effective, Legal Performance Reviews. You’ll get the hands-on tools you need to conduct fair and accurate performance reviews. For instance:
book cover
  • 5 evaluation tools to turn around problem employees
  • 8 strategies for clear and realistic performance standards
  • The 6 mistakes to avoid in your next performance review
  • The right way to identify employee shortcomings and how to overcome them
  • The “secret” test your job descriptions must pass or you face a nasty lawsuit
  • What you must do before the review session even starts
  • And much more!
Turn your most dreaded management task into a positive experience for you and your employees. If this book doesn’t help you do this, then we’ll refund every penny. You have nothing to lose, and only motivated and happy employees to gain. Order your copy today.

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: