Employment Background Check Guidelines: Complying with the Fair Credit Reporting Act, conducting credit background checks and running a criminal check to avoid negligent-hiring lawsuits.

Does law protect Bible study on company premises?

Question: “A co-worker has sent a companywide e-mail inviting employees to attend a morning prayer and Bible study on company premises prior to work hours. Is this allowable by law?”  — Anonymous

 

See Comments Below



Employment Background Check Guidelines: Complying with the Fair Credit Reporting Act, conducting credit background checks and running a criminal check to avoid negligent-hiring lawsuits.


57 Responses to "Does law protect Bible study on company premises?"

 
Fellow Admin Asst
said this on 24 Jul 2009 12:47:21 PM EST
I believe that falls under solicitation and distribution, and possibly harrassment, in the workplace. You should check your employee handbook for specifics outlined by your company. We cannot solicit ANYTHING at any time during working hours - during your breaks or lunch you can do what you like but not to be intrusive on others. Using the company computer & e-mail system is probably not OK since it is during working hours. I had a co-worker put her Jehovah Witness Watchtower magazine on my desk now and then. I didn't like it at all. I was able to tell her myself that I was not interested. Religion is tricky at work and you don't want to end up being considered harrassing someone else because of their religion. You're probably better off ignoring that e-mail. I'm sure others feel the way you do and someone is bound to bring it to HR. If she continues, your safest response would be to reply to her e-mail and ask her to delete you from her e-mail list.

 
Jim Fields
said this on 31 Jul 2009 2:49:14 PM EST
harrassment? don't be silly......

 
Faye Frost
said this on 31 Jul 2009 4:03:28 PM EST
Amen!

 
Woman of God
said this on 05 Aug 2009 12:19:08 PM EST
If it wasn't for God, we wouldn't be here and with all the junk that is going on in the world, we need prayer. It is time for Christians to stand up for their beliefs, instead of worrying about offending others. Being a Chriistian isn't a religion, religion is man made, but having a relationship with the Lord Jesus Christ is important.

 
Min
said this on 24 Jul 2009 1:00:46 PM EST
I personally don't see anything wrong with this. I would assume (or hope) that she got permission to use whatever area this is being held in. Other than that, it's not being held on company time. It's an invitation advising you of this optional event, not harassment. If you're not interested, don't go. (As far as using the company e-mail to distribute the information, it may or may not be against the company's policy, but I wouldn't consider it illegal. She may have also gotten permission to send the e-mail beforehand.)

 
MinCA
said this on 24 Jul 2009 1:03:27 PM EST
I agree with Min, this does not appear to be a solicitation (the person is not giving a Bible lesson in the e-mail) but rather an invitation for those who may be interested. If you are not interested, delete it and move on.

 
Kristie
said this on 24 Jul 2009 1:19:14 PM EST
One could also turn the coin here - what about a generic invitation to a party at a bar for drinks afterwork... there are people out there that don't drink & would be offended by gathering together coworkers at a bar - but no one would think twice about that kind of email... Oh - and don't forget those 'jokes' that get shuffled around the company email that some might find mildly offensive.
The only thing that could possibly be addressed would be the use of the company email system for non-work related messages... but be careful - that is very tricky ground... just remember - tit for tat... if non-work related email is not allowed, HR needs to be prepared to crack down on ALL non-work related email - and not just one person because the invite happened to be regarding something religious.

 
Lilly
said this on 30 Jul 2009 11:26:53 AM EST
I think the difference is employees wouldn't be having drinks on company premises - this is off-site, after work. The person in the question wants to do this on company premises and religion is a lot more touchy subject than socializing after work. It could also me misinterpreted that the company is supporting this particular thing if they allow on site (e.g., most companies have a restriction on the volunteer organizations they support, stay away from political, religous, ect)

 
Kathy B
said this on 31 Jul 2009 3:05:26 PM EST
Kristy
I could not have said it better myself. I agree.

 
Nancy
said this on 24 Jul 2009 1:37:32 PM EST
This is not against the law, nor do I see anything wrong with it. You said it was before work hours inthe morning, and it was simply an invitation. An invitation to join them does not mean you have to go. If the company owners/managers are okay with it then she has done nothing wrong.

 
fellow AA
said this on 24 Jul 2009 2:09:45 PM EST
The short answer would be yes - this is allowable by law. However, I can see this turning into a very sensitive HR issue. Is sending a company wide email invitation considered proper use of company technology; if the meeting is on company property do they allow other groups (religious or otherwise) the same opportunity; the list could go on and on.

 
Jocelyn
said this on 24 Jul 2009 3:16:56 PM EST
Personally it should be a conflict of interest for the company to allow those kind of emails, appropriate emailing should be company policy, and here that would be considered inappropriate.

 
Tina
said this on 24 Jul 2009 3:33:01 PM EST
I think that if you hold a meeting of any sort on company property the company could be liable for harassment whether it was approved or not. Any conceived harassment that can be tied back to the employer (in this case) by their using the company's computer to distribute, could come back to haunt the employer(s) unfortunately. The employee should ask people in person during break times or not involve the company property.

 
Dona
said this on 24 Jul 2009 5:20:05 PM EST
The following is just one example of the government stating that if other types of invitations are allowed, this type is also allowed. Therefore, it is NOT illegal nor harassment.

GUIDELINES ON RELIGIOUS EXERCISE AND RELIGIOUS EXPRESSION IN THE FEDERAL WORKPLACE

THE WHITE HOUSE
Office of the Press Secretary
For Immediate Release....August 14, 1997

The following Guidelines, addressing religious exercise and religious expression, shall apply to all civilian executive branch agencies, officials, and employees in the Federal workplace.

Section 1. Guidelines for Religious Exercise and Religious Expression in the Federal Workplace.
A.Religious Expression.
(B)Religious Discrimination. Federal agencies may not discriminate against employees on the basis of their religion, religious beliefs, or views concerning religion.
(2)Coercion of Employee's Participation or Nonparticipation in Religious Activities.
Examples
(b)On a bulletin board on which personal notices unrelated to work regularly are permitted, a supervisor may post a flyer announcing an Easter musical service at her church with a handwritten notice inviting co-workers to attend. but A supervisor should not circulate a memo announcing that he will be leading a lunch-hour Talmud class that employees should attend in order to participate in a discussion of career advancement that will convene at the confusion of the class.

 
Patty
said this on 27 Jul 2009 8:57:31 AM EST
Touche!

 
Tori
said this on 27 Jul 2009 10:04:41 AM EST
There are probably a lot of technicalities that exist with something like this. We are a large global firm and have been instructed by HR that we can't conduct anything religious on the premises for legal reasons. From my understanding, it would fall under discrimination laws. Aside from this, even if it really is not a legal issue, it is definitely an HR issue. People can take offense to it, even if they partake in that religion.

In this firm, we can't have a religious figure distributing ashes on Ash Wednesday, even if they are also an employee. We have a lot of Deacons who work here. No group prayers can be conducted. No Christmas or Kwanza or Hanukah decorations unless it is in your cubicle and put up by the employee of that particular cubicle. There have already been issues with someone hanging a flag in the office. We can't send any emails like this, either, but could post this on the café bulletin board or in the company newsletter under upcoming group/volunteer events. HR would definitely be called down in a lot of cases.

 
Tori
said this on 27 Jul 2009 10:05:55 AM EST
Either way, always check with HR first to see if it can be done.

 
Ms. Faye
said this on 31 Jul 2009 4:08:53 PM EST
How sad.

 
Kathy
said this on 27 Jul 2009 4:17:22 PM EST
At my company, we have a lunchtime Bible study time every other week on company premises. It has all been approved by HR. Notices are only sent to those who have expressed an interest.

 
Dani
said this on 30 Jul 2009 8:48:14 AM EST
I don't think it should have been sent out on company email, however, since it is before work hours, there is nothing wrong with it.

 
Andrea
said this on 30 Jul 2009 3:55:35 PM EST
This could also force non-Christians out of the closet. My husband and I are agnostic and something along these lines happened to him at work and now he is harassed because of his beliefs. It could all start with an innocent "why weren't you at Bible study?" and end in a hostile work environment for individuals who choose not to attend. Anyway, illegal? Not really. A good idea? Probably not.

 
CReadus
said this on 31 Jul 2009 10:41:05 AM EST
I understand that religion and politics are very sensitive subjects in the workplace. However, the last few companies I have worked for promote and embrace other organizations such as Asian American Club, African American Club, Hispanic Club, Gay and Lesbian Club and many other specific group clubs. If these clubs can exist on company time and receive company funding for events why can't Christians, Jews, Seiks, Evangelist, Catholics and any other religion receive equal club rights? Many of the clubs flyers and announcement are ethnic restrictive and not inclusive should someone be offended if they are not included? Where does a company draw the line? And why are these types of groups more important than faith or any less volatile?

 
Michele
said this on 31 Jul 2009 2:48:32 PM EST
Not trying to be ignorant, but AMERICA is a FREE COUNTRY, you can chose to go to the Bible Study and Morning Prayer or chose not to. There is no law that prohibits Religion in a work place. I work in a world of multicultural. Everyone can make their own choice. Why do people in and out of work constantly have to go on and on about such petty things? That's whay I want to know.

 
Abigale
said this on 31 Jul 2009 2:53:19 PM EST
Isn't it amazing that our "freedom of religion" right is so offensive. Come on people. Kristie is right, tit for tat. Choose your battles

 
Heather
said this on 31 Jul 2009 2:55:44 PM EST
This is what is wrong with America, we analyze every single thing to death and one can barely breath with out thinking that it might offend another person. We need to stop worying about how this will or won't offend someone. If you are that hung up on recieveing an e-mail inviting you to a religious meeting than perhaps you should move to another country where you have no choice but to do what the goverment says.

 
Mel
said this on 31 Jul 2009 2:55:51 PM EST
The Bible is not hurting anyone. If most copmany was not so guilty of dirty dealings and backstabbing they should not be so worried about the Bible. An this is a free country.

 
Sue
said this on 31 Jul 2009 3:22:25 PM EST
Better yet - this Country was founded by Christian For-fathers that had daily prayer meetings before each of their Continental Congress meetings for hours. As we lose our Rights & Freedoms of such things as Religion and Speech, we are losing our For-fathers ideals and foundation for making this Country what they fought for in the first place. This is from a website called www.wallbuilders.com. It even amazed me that our four fathers were SO into prayer before such a monumental undertaking - Revolution!

 
Deb
said this on 31 Jul 2009 3:02:02 PM EST
It is using company property for personal business and has no place there.

 
Gloria
said this on 31 Jul 2009 3:04:30 PM EST
In this evil world, we need prayer and bible study. I am glad this person had the courage to say so. As long as it is permitted by HR; it's okay and it is permitted by HR. It seems this was an open invitation, not a harrassment!

 
Kathy B
said this on 31 Jul 2009 3:15:06 PM EST
We spend such a great deal of our lives at the workplace it is almost impossible NOT to bring some part of one's belief system to it. For some, the belief system permeates every part of life and dictates integral behavior. Asking this person to separate their "religious life" from their "work life" is not that simple.
On another note, the person who is interested in receiving emails about, and participating in Bible studies with co-workers is probably the one who does NOT get offended at "Happy Hour" invites and graciously turns down the invitations or politely requests removal from email invite lists. is it possible for ALL to be so gracious?

 
Eric
said this on 22 Sep 2009 5:44:49 PM EST
I like what you are saying here Kathy. You can't live two different lives. Christians are excited about their faith and should be....they inherit eternal life.

 
Becki
said this on 31 Jul 2009 3:17:25 PM EST
My company is a Christian company. We do not shove it down anybodies throats, but we let everyone know that this company is a Christian company and we believe we are successful because of the presence of the Lord. We also offer a Chaplain Care Team - a personal support program for all employees and their families - which has helped employee moral quiet a bit.
When management first decided to let everyone know our beliefs I was honestly very worried about it, but the support throughout this company is amazing. I don't see a single problem with asking about bible study, all she did was offer - it is up to the fellow employee to go or not.

 
Tina
said this on 31 Jul 2009 3:30:32 PM EST
I wish my company was like that. I am a Christian but do not get support like that here.

 
Rose
said this on 31 Jul 2009 3:20:27 PM EST
In our organization if there is someone that wants to hold a meeting, etc., we have a form that people fill out to ask for use of the facilities. I don't know about other organizations, but once that form is filled out and everything is approved, they can go ahead and use the facilities for whatever meeting it is. I know we receive a lot of e-mails that pertain to jokes, etc. and don't think anything of it. Why should this be any different. If you don't like it, don't respond, just delete it, but don't try to dictate to everyone else. Live and let live.

 
Sue
said this on 31 Jul 2009 3:24:33 PM EST
Right on! There is Freedom to choose what we want or don't want still...

 
Anonymous
said this on 31 Jul 2009 3:23:32 PM EST
Does it matter if the "company" is a state or federal organization? Does that make any difference?

 
Anonymous
said this on 31 Jul 2009 4:02:17 PM EST
What about the political correctness of allowing employees of different religions to stop, use a prayer matt and pray several times a day. Several companies would bend over backward to allow "diversity." What's the difference of that or a traditional bible study? I love living in a country to do what I want when I want.

 
Ilja
said this on 31 Jul 2009 4:18:04 PM EST
The whole issue is a form of intolerance. When someone doesn't like or approve of something they try to get a rule that nobody else can like or approve it either And that is the base of most man-made problems. Let's help prevent and/or solve problems, not make new ones.

 
Skeptic
said this on 31 Jul 2009 4:36:01 PM EST
Another issue to think about is of safety..... what if one of the attendees is involved in some type of mishap? Chances are workers comp may be an issue. Is there another venue that this group could meet at rather than work?

 
Kate
said this on 31 Jul 2009 4:54:25 PM EST
What safety issue? They get angry and pound each other with their bibles?

Just joking.

 
JaneC
said this on 31 Jul 2009 4:56:58 PM EST
Why are the disciples etched in stone all over Washington D.C.? Because we are a country that was founded based on christian morals and ideas. Ya know, one nation, under God... ? If we as christians must be tolerant of other views and religions being practiced in our own country, then isn't it fair that others are tolerant of our religion and what brings us joy as well? This just seems like common sense and playing fair, and brotherhood to me, not something that we need a law about. Can't we all just get along?

 
Joyce
said this on 31 Jul 2009 5:11:21 PM EST
I like to keep business and personal separate, unless religion is part of the business. OR, it is a company like Becki's that is know as a Christian business from the beginning. Otherwise, if you open it up to one religion, you have to open up to others. Bible study sounds harmless enough, but wicca and voodoo can also be considered a religion. And there are others that may be even more off the road that most walk. Lots to think about. Easy way out -- separate business from personal. Meet off-site, do not use company computers to solicit. Maybe an employee board in the lunchroom to post outside activities?

 
bush
said this on 31 Jul 2009 5:15:11 PM EST
It is so amazing. People can come in play all types of music in the workplace. Have conversations about any and everything, but as soon as someone brings up a "Faith" subject or comment...everyone becomes super sensitive/offended. I guess the reason we are in the condition we are in right now!

 
bush
said this on 31 Jul 2009 5:19:13 PM EST
resubmit
This is so amazing to me. People can come in and play all types of music in the workplace; have conversations about any and everything, but as soon as someone brings up a "Faith" subject or comment...everyone becomes super sensitive/offended. I guess that is the reason we are in the condition we are in right now!

 
Anonymous
said this on 03 Aug 2009 10:25:17 AM EST
AMEN!

 
Julie
said this on 31 Jul 2009 6:24:25 PM EST
I work for a large corporate company. We have all kinds of cultural clubs here -- Asian, Hispanic, African American, Gay & Lesbian. We also have sports clubs, chess club and others. I believe by law if a company allows one type of extra-cirricular activity to take place on company premises, it cannot dis-allow others. We had a Bible study here for quite a while --once a week during lunch hour. The leader received permission from HR and our Legal department before starting it; and before she sent out the original email invitation, she asked people personally (face-to-face, but on company premises) if they would be interesed in participating. I believe that's what the lawyer she talked to recommended. People who expressed an interest were invited. The leader later got too busy and was not able to continue it and no one else wanted to or was able to pick up the leadership to continue it, but it was nice to have it when we did. I think, as a result of the Bible study, religious conversations are more open and you have that "network" of Christian friends at work. You don't feel shy or backward to ask someone to pray for you or tell them you'll be praying for them -- or even send out a broadcast to the "network" (the old Bible Study team) and ask for prayer. As to the comment about using email for anyting religious, I agree with Kristie -- once you open that door, HR would have to be ready to crack down on any type of personal email, otherwise, it would be discrimination (same with club activities on company premises). I also agree with bush's comments -- any type of conversation seems OK and people have no problem telling dirty jokes or using the name of Jesus as a swear word on company premises. We, as Christians, need to be salt and light in the workplace and lift up the name of Jesus. Where is our testimony?

 
Lisa P
said this on 01 Aug 2009 3:46:26 PM EST
Good grief! People sure get bent out of shape over some petty stuff. Yes, a private company can determine what types of activities take place on their property, and can even forbid certain types of conversation, such as religion and politics, during company time, but come on. The lady wants to have a bible study on her own time and invited you. You don't want to go, don't go. If she invited you to join her knitting circle before work, would you be upset? I doubt it.

For the record, I am not a bible believing Christian. I do not attend church and would not be interested in attending a bible study.

Also, to correct earlier posters, our country was not founded by Christians based on Christian values. Our country was founded by deists (look it up) and was founded on moral values held by almost all religions. Also, God does not belong exclusively to Christians.

Hmmm. Maybe this sort of thing is why people get bent out of shape over an email.

 
hr@cyclescentral.com
said this on 03 Aug 2009 9:12:39 AM EST
Kristy, I like what you aid and completely agree with you! Lyn

 
Dina
said this on 03 Aug 2009 1:35:50 PM EST
Just a bunch of hypocrites! This is a free country and what other people do shouldn't be considered infringing on anyone's rights or space. People need to get over it.

 
Joyce Acklin
said this on 03 Aug 2009 3:55:02 PM EST
Why should religious study or prayer be such a threat if you choose not to believe or attend?
Oh, how far we have fallen for this great country having been started because of religious persecution and for freedom of religion. They came to escape this.
Did you know that this was never to be a constituional issue of church and state, but that each state was to decide for itself? It was actually 2 ministers that wrote personal letters to President Jefferson (if memory serves me) who could see that this could be a concern. Look at the original constitution. I don't think you'll find it there. His reply was that it should be decided by each state.
How far we have come.

 
Joyce Acklin
said this on 03 Aug 2009 3:55:03 PM EST
Why should religious study or prayer be such a threat if you choose not to believe or attend?
Oh, how far we have fallen for this great country having been started because of religious persecution and for freedom of religion. They came to escape this.
Did you know that this was never to be a constituional issue of church and state, but that each state was to decide for itself? It was actually 2 ministers that wrote personal letters to President Jefferson (if memory serves me) who could see that this could be a concern. Look at the original constitution. I don't think you'll find it there. His reply was that it should be decided by each state.
How far we have come.

 
Teri
said this on 03 Aug 2009 5:00:55 PM EST
Joyce, Well stated!

The notice is sent out to inform people that there is a bible study. It is not mandated.

 
Freda
said this on 04 Aug 2009 8:54:20 AM EST
Heather- I agree w/you totally.

 
Anonymous2
said this on 04 Aug 2009 1:55:06 PM EST
We will always find people who want to complain, criticize, bash, or destroy that which they disagree with or is unknowledgeable about. But, if there is something of interest to them, they wouldn't say a word and would probably support it. (Such babies!) Certainly, if you are not interested in attending the Bible study, don't go and delete the invitation. If there was an invitation to read the well-named TV movie & books about good and evil spirits (as imposed upon some children in some schools) and discuss their mysteries, no one would probably complain, feel harassed, or think twice about offenses. I think Christianity has gotten a bad rap from society because of those who claim to be Christian and do not live up to its principles. Nonetheless, just think of the good that a Bible study or other POSITIVE study group could have on morale, reduction of stress, less workplace conflicts, etc., and the lift of integrity, camaraderie, and commitment to work ethics - if practiced faithfully. I believe we have too many of our God-given rights either taken away or suppressed as it is. We need more tolerance. Tolerance is one of the most challenging attributes of human nature. Yes, we need more of it.

 
Woman of God
said this on 07 Aug 2009 3:42:25 PM EST
Amen!!! Anonymous2

 
Kate
said this on 04 Aug 2009 5:04:23 PM EST
Would you have asked this same question if the person had sent an email selling Girl Scout Cookies, Boy Scout popcorn, subs for the soccer team, etc.; or suggested that folks meet before work to excercise?

 
Andrea
said this on 05 Aug 2009 9:11:58 AM EST
Kate,

In short, yes. Any fund-raising efforts should be word-of-mouth or a sign-up sheet in the break room. Otherwise, co-workers will feel obligated to participate.




Leave a reply:
Your Name *: Email (private): Website:
Please copy the characters from the image below into the text field below. Doing this helps us prevent automated submissions.
Security Code: img