• LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Google+

Former boss’s good reviews don’t prove new boss’s bias

by on
in Discrimination and Harassment,Human Resources,Leaders & Managers,Management Training,Performance Reviews

Some bosses are tougher than others. But when a new boss suddenly gives a lousy performance review to an employee who is used to getting good reviews, the employee may try to blame the change on the new supervisor’s alleged bias.

Absent other evidence, that won’t prove discrimination in court.

Recent case: Thomas Finn was promoted after receiving good reviews from his supervisor. His new boss wasn’t nearly as pleased with Finn and demoted him back to his former position. Later, the new supervisor gave Finn poor reviews for the job in which he had previously been rated highly. Eventually, Finn was fired for poor performance.

He sued, alleging age discrimination and held up the old reviews as proof.

But the court tossed out the case, saying he needed more than that to prove discrimination. (Finn v. J.B. Hunt, No. 07-4851, DC NJ, 2009)

Leave a Comment