The recession has put the brakes on pay raises in many workplaces. But too many employers have halted at the same time. That’s a major mistake.
Reason: Discharged employees who sue will have a much easier time getting to a jury trial if you can’t produce evaluations that back up your stated termination reasons. Without written and predisciplinary evidence, it doesn’t matter what reason you offer. The termination will probably look so suspicious that a judge won’t hesitate to keep the case alive.
Recent case: Minor league umpire Clark Davis, 52, sued for age discrimination, alleging that he was fired because of his age. Davis claimed the league director told him “we’re going to give the younger guys a chance.”
The director argued that he never made that statement. He said Davis was dismissed because he’d played in a Las Vegas poker tournament, which looked bad, and that his performance had deteriorated in recent years.
The league’s problem: It never did , so it couldn’t prove his performance had slipped. Plus, other umpires weren’t disciplined for gambling. All this, the judge concluded, was evidence that the claimed reasons might have been manufactured to cover up a case of age discrimination. A jury will decide. (Davis v. Atlantic League of Professional Baseball Clubs, No. 07-5023, DC NJ, 2009)
- How to Fire an Employee the Legal Way: 6 Termination Guidelines
- 10 Secrets to an Effective Performance Review
- Block firing-Bias charge by documenting business reason
- ADA lawsuits take an ominous turn: Court rules EEOC can file group claims
- Porn at work: Don't get into debate over what is 'Too much'
- Supreme Court rejects EEOC's broad definition of 'supervisor'