Employers can’t fire employees in retaliation for “blowing the whistle” on illegal activities. But Minnesota’s Whistleblower Statute doesn’t apply to workers who complain about practices they simply think are unethical.
Recent case: Naomi Chial worked as a retail sales manager, selling mobile phones and service contracts in Sprint’s Twin Cities market. Sometimes, Sprint customers want to add a line to an existing account. When another sales manager suggested that salespeople could earn greater commissions by claiming such add-ons as new accounts, Chial objected. She reported the practice to higher-level managers. Then Sprint fired her.
Chial sued, alleging she had been fired for whistle-blowing.
But the 8th Circuit Court of Appeals ruled she had no case because, when she complained, she didn’t believe the practice was actually illegal. She simply thought it was unethical. (Chial v. Sprint, No. 08-2012, 8th Cir., 2009)
- How to Fire an Employee the Legal Way: 6 Termination Guidelines
- Public employers, take note: Some employee speech may be protected
- Medical marijuana: ADA protection up in smoke
- Boss threatens retaliation? You can still save the day
- When reasonable accommodation is time off, it's OK to count it as FMLA leave