Before an employee can sue for retaliation, she has to show she participated in some form of protected activity—filing an EEOC or internal discrimination complaint, for example.
But what about refusing to cooperate with an employer’s investigation?
Recent case: Carolyn Miller is of German descent. A statue of a German soldier and a fake military certificate showed up on her desk.
When HR learned about the incident, it told Miller to remove the items while it investigated. Miller refused to cooperate, perceiving the demand as anti-Germanic discrimination.
She was fired shortly after and sued, alleging she was fired for refusing to participate in the investigation.
The court dismissed the case, concluding such a refusal was not protected activity. (Miller v. Empress Casino, No. 09-C-760, ND IL, 2009)
- ADA: Use these criteria to keep courts from second-guessing job's 'essential functions'
- Refusal to hire non-Hispanics sparks EEOC lawsuit
- How do the new Illinois Equal Pay Act rules affect my record-keeping obligations?
- If employee won't admit disability, what are our reasonable accommodation obligations?
- If we have to lay off employees, is severance pay mandatory?