Employee theft is a huge problem, and employers are sometimes tempted to make an example of a thief. They hope to discourage other employees from stealing. It’s a bad idea, because the alleged thief may sue for defamation.
Instead, keep the information as confidential as possible. In the following case, the employer did everything right.
Recent case: Christopher Mosley worked for Roadway Express at its Houston terminal. During a shift, someone stole a trailer loaded with plasma screen televisions. Surveillance tapes showed Mosley acting suspiciously, and concluded he had shown the thief which trailer to take.
Roadway fired Mosley, and he sued, alleging defamation.
The court rejected his claim, noting the employer had kept the information confidential and shared it only with those who needed to make the termination decision. (Mosley v. Roadway Express, No. H-07-1406, SD TX, 2009)
- How to Fire an Employee the Legal Way: 6 Termination Guidelines
- 10 Secrets to an Effective Performance Review
- When an improvement becomes a big problem
- Can we reduce pay for exempt employee who will miss work for intermittent FMLA leave?
- Helping Employees Through the Grieving Process
- Rule against document removal supports legit business need