When hiring a new leader for your team, it’s essential to interview his or her direct reports so you can smoke out any nasty surprises.
People learn what they want in a leader by finding out what they don’t want. If you encounter any of these responses, probe around:
- “We were served a ‘priority du jour.’ He changed his mind all the time and reversed big decisions.”
- “Sometimes she yelled at us for delivering bad news.”
- “He bullied people in front of everybody, even customers.”
- “If you told her anything was going wrong, she would march right to the culprit and basically rat you out.”
- “He doesn’t trust any of us. He micromanages the managers and their people.”
- “I thought he was a poor judge of talent. He hired three fast talkers.”
- “She just wanted a ‘strategy’ to dangle in front of the CEO and the board, not one that we could hope to actually deliver.”
Any of these answers alone is a red flag. If you get one, be sure to ask others about that behavior to determine if there are patterns or flukes.
Even if you firmly intend to hire a candidate after hearing some sketchy remarks, these interviews can provide insights that will put you on a better footing.
— Adapted from The Right Leader: Selecting Executives Who Fit, Nat Stoddard with Claire Wyckoff, John Wiley & Sons.