Joe Fitzpatrick told his supervisor that he was considering resigning and asked about getting one of the bonus checks that other members of his work group had received. "I have a check for you in my pocket ... All you have to do is tell me you are staying," the boss said. Fitzpatrick opted to leave, and sued for the unpaid bonus. He lost.
The reason: Under Maryland's wage law, once a bonus, commission orhas been promised, the employee is entitled to it. But when Fitzpatrick was hired, he was promised a profit-sharing bonus after two years of employment, and he stayed for only one year. Because the company considered paying the bonus a year earlier than the agreed-upon terms, the money was merely "a gift, a gratuity" and not wages, the court said. So it was revocable at any time. (Whiting-Turner Contracting Co. v. Fitzpatrick, No. 9, Md. Ct. of Appeals, 2001)
Advice: When it comes to money, always make sure everything is crystal clear. Legal experts say the gloomy economy is sparking more lawsuits like this among employees watching every penny.
Be sure you know how your state law defines compensation that must be paid when an employee leaves, such as commissions,or other promised amounts.
Also, remember that the way you handle bonuses can affect the overtime rate you must pay nonexempt workers under the federal Fair Labor Standards Act. Truly discretionary bonuses aren't calculated as part of a nonexempt worker's regular rate. But attendance, productivity and other similar bonuses are.
- How to Fire an Employee the Legal Way: 6 Termination Guidelines
- Could he sue us? Employee was fired after he injured himself on the job
- Intermittent FMLA leave is a pain, but don't deny it for that reason
- Want to offer additional leave for disability? Be sure policy is drafted in your favor
- Congress begins debate on paid-leave bill; Obama OKs same-sex benefits for federal workers