Why HSAs are better than MSAs — Business Management Daily: Free Reports on Human Resources, Employment Law, Office Management, Office Communication, Office Technology and Small Business Tax Business Management Daily

Why HSAs are better than MSAs

by on
in Small Business Tax,Small Business Tax Deduction Strategies

While Health Savings Accounts (HSAs) are similar in many ways to old-fashioned Medical Savings Accounts (MSAs), the new accounts are also much better. Here's why:


• Smaller insurance deductible allowed. You can qualify for an HSA with an insurance policy carrying a much lower deductible than what's needed to qualify for an MSA (as low as $1,000 for single coverage with an HSA versus no lower than $1,700 for an MSA, and as low as $2,000 for family coverage with an HSA versus $3,450 for an MSA).

HSAs carry higher annual out-of-pocket maximums (as high as $5,000 for single coverage versus no more than $3,450 for an MSA; as high as $10,000 for family coverage versus $6,300 for an MSA).

Bottom line: It's much easier to find policies that meet the HSA guidelines than those that meet the MSA requirements. Many large insurance companies offer policies passing muster under the HSA rules.

• Bigger contributions allowed. With an HSA, you can contribute up to 100 percent of the insurance policy deductible amount (limited to $2,600 for single coverage and $5,150 for family coverage). In contrast, MSA contributions limit the deductible for single coverage to only 65 percent or 75 percent for family coverage.

• Larger contributions for older people. HSAs permit larger contributions for those age 55 and older (see box, page 4). MSAs don't offer that advantage.

• HSAs are permanent. MSAs existed only as a "pilot project," with periodical renewal by Congress. In contrast, HSAs are permanently installed in the tax law.

• All size businesses can jump in. Employer-sponsored HSAs are available to both large and small employers alike. In contrast, MSAs are only allowed for small employers (generally those with 50 or fewer workers).

Leave a Comment