You don’t have to bargain with union formed by coercion — Business Management Daily: Free Reports on Human Resources, Employment Law, Office Management, Office Communication, Office Technology and Small Business Tax Business Management Daily

You don’t have to bargain with union formed by coercion

by on
in Employment Law,Human Resources

During an organizing campaign at a clay processing plant, pro-union senior staffers routinely threatened production and maintenance employees, telling them to support the union or else they'd be "squeezed like a lemon," "squeezed out of a job" and "left hanging in the wind."

After a close vote, the union won. But the company refused to recognize the election, calling it invalid because pro-union staff coerced employees.

The National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) sought to enforce the union order. A federal appeals court disagreed and rejected the NLRB's ruling.

The court said a free election in this case was made impossible by the pro-unioners' job threats, which probably tainted the election. Therefore, the company had no obligation to bargain. (NLRB v. Kentucky Tennessee Clay Co., No. 01-2202, 4th Cir., 2002)

Advice: You have the power to challenge bogus elections. Unions aren't free to dump all election campaign responsibilities on untrained employee-organizers, then bury their heads in the sand while those organizers bully co-workers into voting for the union.

This decision is a definite win for employers in the 4th Circuit, but employment attorneys say the ruling will have a larger reach. While courts have never looked favorably on union organizers' overt acts or threats of violence, they'll also be tightening up on union elections that use nonviolent, behind-the-scenes intimidation tactics.

Leave a Comment