It’s a cardinal sin under the
If you outsource to another company to administer your FMLA process, work closely with it to ensure you aren’t firing an employee who has been approved for FMLA leave. Instead, make it standard practice to double-check FMLA status before taking any employment action.
Recent case: Joann Stephenson worked for Nokia as director of global benefits. She missed work frequently, seldom even bothering to call in. Some days, she didn’t show up until late afternoon. Consequently, her work suffered. She was placed on a performance improvement plan and told that future absences wouldn’t be tolerated.
That’s when Stephenson began asking for disability and FMLA leave. Nokia outsourced administration of those benefits to a third-party provider, which gave Stephenson the appropriate forms. Meanwhile, HR decided to terminate Stephenson when she didn’t return from a short FMLA leave that had been approved.
Unfortunately for Nokia, when it terminated Stephenson, the administrator had already approved an additional period of FMLA leave. Stephenson sued, alleging interference with FMLA leave.
The court said a jury should decide whether Nokia either retaliated against Stephenson or purposely tried to deny her leave. (Stephenson v. Nokia, No. 3:06-CV-2204, ND TX, 2008)
Final note: There are two lessons in this case. (1) If you use an FMLA administrator, check to make sure it hasn’t approved additional leave before you discharge an employee for not returning from leave. (2) Don’t wait to discipline an employee who obviously isn’t working out. Stephenson probably could have been discharged much earlier, before she ever asked for FMLA leave.
- Your 10-point checklist for ensuring an NLRA-compliant handbook
- Never let fired employee unfairly blame bias; be prepared to prove performance deficiencies
- When labor, immigration laws clash, NLRB decides
- Banning religious jokes: Seems extreme, but it could have saved Haddonfield in court
- Use fair progressive discipline and clear documentation to prove you're not biased