Sometimes, it looks like an employee has been performing just fine—until someone discovers that her work was really subpar all along.
Before you discipline or fire the worker, document what you discovered (and when) so you can explain away prior good.
Recent case: Miriam, who is Hispanic and from Panama, worked for an agency that provides residential services to adults with developmental disabilities.
She was in charge of creating treatment plans and tracking residents’ personal spending to ensure their funds were accounted for.
Then, irregularities were discovered with those records.decided it had to hire additional personnel to fix the problem and also revise the job description for the position Miriam held. It now requires a bachelor’s degree, which Miriam lacked.
Miriam was fired, both because she no longer met the job requirements and because of her.
She sued, alleging race and national-origin discrimination.
The court tossed out her lawsuit, noting that the agency had discovered deficiencies in Miriam’s work and that changing the job requirements was a legitimate business move under the circumstances. (Hanzer v. Mentor Network, No. 14-4333, 3rd Cir., 2015)
- How to Fire an Employee the Legal Way: 6 Termination Guidelines
- Annual checkup: Your top 10 employment law to-do's in 2010
- Use consistent hiring, firing processes to knock down age discrimination claims
- Do I receive tax benefits for COBRA payments?
- Bankruptcy can lead to dismissal of discrimination suits