Want to look good to a judge? Then take the extra time to let employees tell their side of the story before you fire them.
Recent case: Leandra worked at a Nutrisystem call center until she was fired for allegedly spending work time on personal projects, dropping calls and treating callers rudely.
She sued, alleging that she really had been fired in retaliation for an earlier complaint she made about rude co-workers and supervisors. Leandra also claimed that she hadn’t dropped any calls. Rather, she said, she had been issued a defective phone that sometimes cut off callers.
But Nutrisystem was ready. It told the judge that before it made the final discharge decision, it let Leandra explain her actions. At that time, Leandra admitted doing personal work while she was supposed to be handling calls.
Plus, when Leandra informed HR that she hadn’t dropped the calls, the company checked her equipment. It found nothing wrong, so it fired her.
The court said Nutrisystem acted fairly and legally. It fired Leandra for legitimate business reasons. The case was dismissed. (Allen v. Nutrisystem, No. 13-2505, 3rd Cir., 2013)
Final note: Although an employer can fire an at-will employee for a frivolous reason (or even no reason at all), it helps to use a fair and reasonable one. That way, the employee can’t argue she was singled out because of her membership in a protected class.
- Federal laws on employee discrimination: what managers need to know
- Cut your risk! Have HR make firing decisions
- Is employee being set up to fail? Beware boss's criticism of 'soft' skills
- What factors should we weigh when deciding whether to offer severance package?
- How your management style can stop workplace violence