While most employers have to follow federal and state anti-discrimination laws, there is a limited exception for religious organizations.
Under the ministerial exception, an employee hired to preach the organization’s religious beliefs can’t sue for discrimination.
Recent case: Frank, who is over age 40, was discharged from his job as a preacher for an African Methodist Episcopal Church.
He sued, claiming age discrimination, harassment (alleging he had to work in a hostile work environment) and retaliation.
The court quickly dismissed his lawsuit, noting that as a preacher, Frank was ministering and delivering religious messages for the church.
That put him squarely in the ministerial exception to discrimination laws under the free exercise of religion clause in the Constitution. (Saunders v. Jefferson, et al., No. 5:12-CV-511, ED NC, 2013)
- Best way to thwart discrimination lawsuits: Have manager who hired also handle the firing
- Nine years later, Prudential settlement not quite settled
- Background checks, employee investigations and the FCRA
- Orthopedic manufacturer settles religious bias suit
- Replacing worker with someone slightly younger isn't age bias