Good news for bosses who get nervous when required to giveevaluations: A negative alone isn’t grounds for a lawsuit.
It’s only if the review becomes the basis for discharge, demotion or a denied promotion that employees can take the matter to court.
Recent case: Elias complained he was singled out and retaliated against for complaining about discrimination based on his Native American origin. His evidence: a poor review he received after he had complained.
Elias was later fired for reasons unrelated to the review. He sued, arguing that the review itself was proof of discrimination.
The court disagreed. It said that reviews alone don’t amount to adverse employment actions. (Murdock v. LA Fitness, No. 12-975, DC MN, 2013)
- Go on offense to establish defense: Train staff in anti-harassment rules
- HR: Carefully review firing plans; courts will frown on 'rubber stamp'
- Keep 'Customer Preference' Out of Your Hiring Criteria
- Employees fighting? Punish everyone equitably—or be prepared to explain why not
- No need to bend seniority rules to accommodate disabled employees