It’s sad but true: Anyone can file a lawsuit for any reason. However, don’t let the fear of litigation keep you from making necessary decisions. Sometimes, you have to discipline employees for the good of the organization.
As long as you are reasonably confident you haven’t broken any laws and have good records showing you treat all employees fairly and equally, you won’t lose a meritless lawsuit.
Recent case: Ellis, who is black and over 60 years old, worked for United Rentals of America until he quit to move to another state for personal reasons. He soon changed his mind and applied for an open position at a United Rentals store near his new home.
He was hired. For two years he performed well. Then supervisors began to notice that Ellis sometimes allowed equipment to be rented when it hadn’t been properly prepared. Ellis received several written warnings, including one that informed him the next incident would mean termination.
Six days later, Ellis again allowed some equipment to be rented before it had been properly serviced and prepared. He was fired this time.
He sued, alleging age and race discrimination. But he couldn’t come up with anything as evidence of discrimination, other than a hunch.
That wasn’t good enough, especially when measured against company records showing that United Rentals had rehired Ellis knowing his age and race. The case was tossed out. (Dees v. United Rentals North America, No. 12-30477, 5th Cir., 2013)
- How to Fire an Employee the Legal Way: 6 Termination Guidelines
- Supreme Court: Fewer small firms covered by ADA, but check state law
- Use 'Soft' criteria for staffing decisions? Be prepared to back up rationale
- The space between: How applicants age themselves
- Beware! Single age comment might mean lawsuit