More employees these days are taking their grumblings about work (and their co-workers) from the office to the virtual watercoolers of Facebook, Twitter and other online outposts.
But as a new ruling shows, it’s best to avoid punishing workers for discussing workplace issues online, especially if those e-chats are being held among co-workers. Such online discussions could be deemed “concerted activity” that’s protected under federal, even if you’re a nonunion workplace.
Recent case: An employee of a New York nonprofit group posted this on her personal Facebook page, “Lydia Cruz, a co-worker, feels that we don’t help our clients enough … I about had it! My fellow co-workers, how do u feel?”
Four off-duty employees responded to the post, objecting to Cruz’s alleged comment about their poor work. The nonprofit fired the worker who posted the original message, plus the four co-workers, saying all five violated the company’s zero-tolerance policy on “bullying and harassment.” The nonprofit was not a unionized workplace.
The National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) sided with the workers, saying the firing violated the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA).
The NLRB said the employees’ Facebook comments did fall within the definition of “concerted activity” for their mutual aid and protection.
That’s because the comments, the NLRB said, “were taking a first step towards taking group action to defend themselves against the accusations” that they believed would be taken to. The NLRB said the comments could not be construed as harassment, as the nonprofit argued. (Hispanics United of Buffalo Inc., 359 NLRB No. 37)
Bottom line: This important ruling “demonstrates an expansion of the NLRB’s traditional definition of protected concerted activity,” says the Jackson Lewis law firm.
As a result, employers should be increasingly cautious about disciplining or firing workers based on their communications—both online and off—relating to the workplace. As Jackson Lewis notes, this decision, “opens the door to the argument that any discussion among co-workers pertaining to workplace matters could be considered ‘protected’ under the NLRA.”
- How to Fire an Employee the Legal Way: 6 Termination Guidelines
- Converting employees into contractors? Prepare for expensive, protracted litigation
- Messed up? 'Fess up! Honest mistakes aren't evidence of bias
- It's not whistle-blowing! Challenge minor complaints
- How does FMLA leave overlap with paid vacation, sick and personal leave?