• LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Google+

The details matter when documenting discipline

by on
in Firing,Human Resources

The next time you discipline an em­­ployee, consider how his conduct compares to others who broke a similar rule. Then detail the differences if the punishment varies. That way, you can later explain why two employees violating a similar rule deserved different punishments.

Recent case: When Brian broke up with his co-worker Gina, he allegedly threatened her so much that she sought a restraining order against him. He ignored it twice, including once in their employer’s parking lot. Brian was fired under a no-threats-or-violence rule.

He sued, alleging that Gina should also have been fired for bringing a gun to work.

The court dismissed Brian’s lawsuit after learning that Gina brought the gun out of fear for her life, not to en­­gage in violence. The court reasoned the two employees weren’t similarly situated and could be punished differently. (Bond v. City of Bethlehem, No. 11-4291, 3rd Cir., 2012)

Leave a Comment