• LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Google+

Common beef, even vulgarity, won’t rule out unemployment

by on
in Compensation and Benefits,Firing,Human Resources

Employees who get into arguments may be violating workplace rules. But that doesn’t mean that firing them cuts off possible unemployment compensation benefits.

Recent case: Paul worked as a laborer. At the end of a shift, he confronted another employee about allegations that Paul was a snitch. Paul told the employee, “I am tired of you telling mother****ing lies about me. Keep my ***damn name off your lips. I will sue you for slander if you keep it up.”

Paul was fired and applied for un­employment. His employer argued that Paul broke a rule prohibiting arguments; therefore he was fired for cause.

The court didn’t buy it, describing the argument as a common workplace disagreement rather than a threat of workplace violence. He got the benefits. (C&W Tank Cleaning v. Bagrowski, No. L-11-1194, Court of Appeals of Ohio, 2012)

Leave a Comment