Employees who get into arguments may be violating workplace rules. But that doesn’t mean that firing them cuts off possible unemployment.
Recent case: Paul worked as a laborer. At the end of a shift, he confronted another employee about allegations that Paul was a snitch. Paul told the employee, “I am tired of you telling mother****ing lies about me. Keep my ***damn name off your lips. I will sue you for slander if you keep it up.”
Paul was fired and applied for unemployment. His employer argued that Paul broke a rule prohibiting arguments; therefore he was fired for cause.
The court didn’t buy it, describing the argument as a common workplace disagreement rather than a threat of. He got the benefits. (C&W Tank Cleaning v. Bagrowski, No. L-11-1194, Court of Appeals of Ohio, 2012)
- How to Fire an Employee the Legal Way: 6 Termination Guidelines
- Document investigation to thwart harasser's suit
- You can't ask employees to sign away FMLA rights
- Back up consistent discipline system with documentation, review of high-stakes cases
- In RIFs, Show That Economics (Not Age) Drove Your Decision