• LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Google+

Can we demand certification of violent employee’s alleged mental illness?

by on
in Employment Law,Human Resources

Q. One of our employees physically threatened her co-workers. When confronted about the incident, the employee claimed that her behavior resulted from being bipolar. May we ask the employee to provide medical certification to prove that she is bipolar?

To access the entire library of Free Customizable Downloads, you must first register with your email address.

Registration gets you:
  • Free access to 125+ customizable HR Forms
  • Free access to job descriptions, interview questions and hiring checklists for 200 positions.
  • Free access to 18 special reports on HR and management topics.
  • Free weekly email newsletter on HR trends and management
  • Special discounts on our upcoming events
Email Address:

{ 3 comments… read them below or add one }

Louise October 16, 2012 at 11:26 am

Since the employee did not notify the employer of the medical condition until after the threat, the employee is not shielded from discipline for violating workplace policy. The employer can discipline the employee, and then enter into the interactive process regarding an accommodation. Otherwise, employees would be claiming disabilities every time they violate policy.


bbixenstine October 16, 2012 at 8:43 am

karen is right. It is not a reasonable accommodation to excuse an employee from the disciplinary consequences of conduct on the basis of the employee’s disclosure of a disability. The disclosure may be the basis for a last chance agreement, if the employee would other wise have been discharged, and that last chance agreement could involve a requirement of some kind of treatment. If the employee requests some other kind of accommodation (such as leave to get treatment) then, assuming the employee is not justifiably discharged for the threat, the employer has to address the request as any other request for accommodation by a disabled person.


karen October 15, 2012 at 2:20 pm

An employer is not required to accommodate a violent employee, as the same represents an undue hardship to the employer. Furthermore, if the offending employee causes harm to others, the employer could be exposed to liability. The existence of a disability does not require an employer to maintain an unsafe work environment. Such a requirement would frustrate the intent of the ADA.


Leave a Comment