Everyone occasionally says something insensitive. Fortunately, verbal blunders can’t form the basis of a lawsuit if the comments occurred ages ago.
Recent case: Janice prepared surgical equipment at a hospital. Over the years, she had several ailments that required operations: knee surgery, carpal tunnel surgery, a hysterectomy and gastric bypass surgery. Following one operation, Janice’s supervisor casually remarked that she had experienced quite a few surgeries for one person, adding that gastric bypass surgery was risky.
Janice was fired several years later for too many unscheduled absences. She sued, alleging the statements proved her supervisor was looking for an excuse to terminate her.
The court didn’t buy it, considering how long ago the comments were made. (Gecewicz v. Henry Ford Macomb Hospital, No. 11-1065, 6th Cir., 2012)
- How to Fire an Employee the Legal Way: 6 Termination Guidelines
- Employee's web gig prompts firing over fire ant antics
- Alcoholism: a disability; drunkenness: a firing offense
- HR pros, take note: Doing your job isn't 'Protected activity'
- Disruptive employee really deserves firing? Don't let FMLA keep you from pulling the trigger