One cardinal rule of law is this: You can only be sued once for all claims related to a particular wrong. Employees can’t continue to sue you over the same discharge, for example, even if they have multiple claims under several laws. That’s why you should always bring to your attorney’s attention any small-claims cases an employee has filed and lost that seem related to his or her employment.
Recent case: Mark Apseloff was fired from his position as a district manager for Family Dollar stores. He immediately filed two small-claims cases against his former employer: in the first, he demanded stock options; in the second, payment for unpaid vacation time. The courts dismissed both small claims.
Three years later Apseloff sued Family Dollar under Ohio’s state discrimination statute, alleging that he had complained to upperabout alleged sex discrimination in his district—purportedly that males were not placed on the registers because they were more prone to stealing—and had been fired in retaliation.
But the 6th Circuit Court of Appeals dismissed his third lawsuit, reasoning that it was related to his first two claims cases because it had to do with his discharge. Employees must bring all related cases together at the same time, and can’t try to inflict “death by a thousand paper cuts” on their employers. (Apseloff v. Family Dollar Stores, No. 06-4200, 6th Cir., 2007)
- How to Fire an Employee the Legal Way: 6 Termination Guidelines
- 10 Secrets to an Effective Performance Review
- You don't have to put up with insubordination
- Annual checkup: Your top 10 employment law to-do's in 2010
- Cut lawsuit risk by filling vacant position with similar person
- Workers gone wild ... and the legal lessons to be learned