Here’s some comfort if you discover a supervisor has made unwise comments to employees: Ambiguous statements probably aren’t enough to form the basis of a hostile work environment claim.
Recent case: Kenneth Huggins, who is black, sued after the school district he worked for investigated student allegations that he had sexually harassed them.
Huggins sued, claiming a hostile environment because his supervisor said his car was “a bomb.” Huggins said the statement was racially based. He also said the sexual harassment charge was retaliation.
The court disagreed and dismissed the case. The supervisor’s statement wasn’t enough evidence to show that the environment was hostile. Plus—because students made the harassment claims—employer retaliation wasn’t valid. (Huggins v. Coatesville Area Schools, No. 10-4484, 3rd Cir., 2011)
- How to Fire an Employee the Legal Way: 6 Termination Guidelines
- Beat bias suits with good business reasons
- Start new year with thorough review of your sexual harassment policies and practices
- Don't sweat details if your discipline decision is sound
- Sex harassment, retaliation cost gourmet company $535K