Supervisors sometimes say incredibly dumb things. But those remarks won’t necessarily create liability—if you have carefully documented.
Recent case: Robert Dickerson worked for a college as a part-time janitor. He has mild mental retardation. He also has a long history of. He filed an EEOC complaint about discrimination following several poor evaluations.
Then he asked his supervisor what he could do to be hired full time. The supervisor offered advice: Don’t sue your employer.
Later, Dickerson was fired for poor performance. He sued, alleging the supervisor’s comment was clear evidence of retaliation.
The court said the remark was “imprudent” but that it was still clear Dickerson was terminated for poor performance. (Dickerson v. Board of Trustees, No. 10-3381, 7th Cir., 2011)
- How to Fire an Employee the Legal Way: 6 Termination Guidelines
- How long must we retain employee records?
- Two employees involved in same incident? Punishment can differ if it's not discriminatory
- Not every complaint is protected activity
- Employee miffed about your decision? That's no reason to tolerate insubordination