Equal treatment is the rule when dealing with similarly situated employees who quit and then try to return to work.
Recent case: Autumn Eaton worked as a corrections officer. Following a car accident, she had trouble walking.
Prison officials assigned Eaton to another cell block, where she would have to walk extensively. She explained her restrictions, but was told if she didn’t accept the assignment, she would have to turn in her badge. She did and left—but then tried to return for the next scheduled shift. She was blocked at the door.
She sued, alleging sex discrimination. She cited a man who kept his job after refusing an assignment, walking out and then returning an hour later.
The 7th Circuit Court of Appeals said that was evidence of possible sex discrimination. (Eaton v. Indiana Department of Corrections, No. 10-3214, 7th Cir., 2011)
- Discharging ill employee for performance? Better make sure you can prove it
- New employee obviously not working out? Let hiring manager be the one who terminates
- Court rejects bid for personal liability under ADA
- Rule No. 1 for evaluations: The employer—not the employee—sets the standards
- EEOC doesn't have to give much warning or detail in lawsuit