Responding to complaints about pornographic and hostile messages displayed on firefighters’ lockers, the New York City Fire Department (FDNY) asked superior officers to oversee the removal of all offensive materials.
When the firefighters’ union asked for a list of such materials, the department said it didn’t have time to prepare one. Hodgepodge cleanup efforts by superior officers led, not surprisingly, to a heated impasse with the firefighters, who argued that lockers are private space. Finally, the FDNY resorted to an unenforced written policy, asking firefighters to strip their lockers bare.
The department has Mayor Bloomberg’s support, but it probably missed an opportunity by refusing to define offensive materials. A few hours of effort might have spared it a confrontation.
Advice: Nonetheless, the city was legally wise to ban the offensive materials, and you should do likewise. Make sure your sexual and general harassment training emphasizes that potentially offensive material has no place in lockers, cubicles or any other area seen by co-workers, customers or the general public.
- How to Fire an Employee the Legal Way: 6 Termination Guidelines
- DHL will deliver $200K for national-origin discrimination
- Supreme Court rules on pre-employment tests and disparate impact
- When promotions are on the line, follow your criteria and beware supervisor bias
- How to establish a sexual harassment defense?