Some employees believe that an employer can’t legally request a medical exam. They’re wrong.
Recent case: Patrick Rawlins was hired as a bus driver for New Jersey Transit and had to undergo training and pass a vision test. He failed twice, and blamed it on faulty testing equipment. However, he passed a test at his optometrist’s office.
But a supervisor, noting that Rawlins still had trouble reading distant signs, demanded retesting. When Rawlins refused, he was terminated.
Rawlins sued, alleging that New Jersey Transit violated the ADA by ordering the exam, arguing that it was treating him as if he were disabled.
The 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals disagreed, concluding that the employer had reasonable grounds to request the exam based on the supervisor’s observations. (Rawlins v. New Jersey Transit, No. 10-4793, 3rd Cir., 2011)
- If new job stinks, requested transfer can be retaliation
- Set harassment policies employees can understand and follow
- You can fire worker out on FMLA leave--just show legitimate work-related reason
- Good news: EEPA does not include retaliation claims
- How not to fire complaining employee: Use pretext, don't document real reasons