What should I do when a co-worker steals my ideas? — Business Management Daily: Free Reports on Human Resources, Employment Law, Office Management, Office Communication, Office Technology and Small Business Tax Business Management Daily

What should I do when a co-worker steals my ideas?

by on
in Admin Pro Forum

Question: “I’m searching for tips on how to handle co-workers who steal, tweak and execute others’ ideas and then smile with glee when receiving recognition for it. How should I handle it? Should I keep my ideas to myself and only share them with upper management or in a group setting where I’ll receive the credit?” —Lisa

Comments

Isn't is amazing how others want to take credit for good ideals. I keep dates/times and the ideal(s) of everything that I come up with. I do not share, unless I truly know the other person can add or improve upon what I have come up with then I always use a "let's work together so we can share the credit attitude", which does work even if I take a secondary seat once it is out there sometimes. Always, if I do this I let the person I have spoken with know someone in upper management like my suggestion to get some additional input from "you" in tweaking this. I always make sure before I let other know the ideals that can save the company money and time I document and let upper management only know, then I suggest who would be of assistance on the project. Its not about you but how it will benefit the company that really counts.

I just read an article about this and their suggestion was to eliminate any doubt about whose idea/suggestions by taking notes. Something like 'we then discussed various ways to elimate the middleman. Mary suggested (whatever), Sue thought trying (whatever), etc.

That way there could be no doubt as to who suggested what, when.

The problem with sharing with one's supervisor is that supervisor's can also be guilty of idea-stealing. The best way is to make suggestions in a group setting or to provide it in writing (email)to more than one person. Although I agree to a point with anonymous about benefitting the company instead of oneself, I believe that a person receiving due credit he/she has earned is good for morale, helps make them more visible for promotions (thus the back-biting), and allows ideas to flow more freely. I have seen departments even become hostile when this type of behavior goes unchecked.

Let's take another viewpoint: the person who took your idea is fully aware of what he/she has done, and probably believes that you will not confront him/her about it. So, do just that: walk up to the person and say, "why did you pass off my idea as your own?" In most cases, the person will be so taken aback that you won't have to worry about a repeat performance. If he/she truly believes they own the idea, tell them that you have proof it's yours and if it happens again, you're going to upper management and personnel. And when it does happen, do just as you promised.

I would use e-mail as a means to convey your idea. Document your idea and e-mail it to the people in your organization who can implement it. Copy your supervisor, so he/she will know who generated the idea. You will then have a record of when the idea was submitted and any responses received.

I track my ideas in my Lotus Notes Journal but I also use cc to key persons as part of a "keeping you in the loop" on what I am working on. This way others are aware of my ideas. Really I believe in the team instead of my own credit however, you want to keep creative juices flowing and encourage people. Stealing ideas stifles creativity and team spirit.

I like the email trail. A tactic I have used is after a meeting where ideas are "shared" I send a follow-up email to the people involved and my supervisor (other supervisors as appropriate) summarizing what was said and done. For instance, "in todays marketing meeting, I suggested we incorporate a new logo into our print ads. John then expounded on this. Sue has agreed to take on the task of contacting design artists...". This way, as ideas are being worked out, there is an understanding that at the very least, it was a team effort and all people, including me and can get their share of the credit.

My supervisor has each of his direct reports submit a 'Weekly Status Report' to him every Friday by 3pm. In that report, we are to document (bullet point) our Weekly Accomplishments, Goals (for the following week), and our Major Challenges / Mitigating Actions. This last section is intended to identify any important issues you are dealing with, to bring it to your supervisor's attention. Aside from noting the issue, also, most importantly, what you are doing about it (i.e. mitigating action).

This is a great forum for documenting our 'ideas', discussions with our peers, issues & solutions, etc. It's been a great tool for all of us.

It's true that folks will often use our ideas as their own. In some way that is flattering. In others it is really annoying, especially if they do not acknowledge us.

But think of the situation where one might spend all of their effort protecting their ideas. They might never complete any of them on their own because more often than not we need the help of others to complete them. Further, spending time and energy continually protecting ideas often inhibits developing new ones. And, an idea is nothing if it is not implemented.

Now imagine someone who has numerous ideas and chooses to freely share them. The best ideas will get developed by them or others, they will be able to move on to newer, bigger, better ideas, and eventually will be recognized as a source of ideas and innovation.

Why do so many of us feel that we'll only have a few good ideas and they must be protected so we get credit? Although it seems counterintuitive, my experience shows that success flows from sharing ideas and efforts more than from protecting them and overtly seeking credit.

{ 4 comments… read them below or add one }

Sessi Zafoun August 20, 2013 at 12:57 pm

Merci Johnny for the info
Nespresso Coffee Club is prejudiced towards gays and lesbians. Nespresso asked their lawyers at Jackson Lewis to request NBC remove the article:
posted an excerpt:
A Manhattan man has filed a complaint with the New York State Division of Human Rights against Nespresso, the giant coffee maker, alleging he was discriminated against by his co-workers for wearing tight jeans. The hilarity stops there, however, as Charlie Batista isn’t some W’burg hipster with an uneven haircut and a trust fund to match.

According to Edge, the discrimination began back in May 2007 when Charlie Batista’s former supervisor Jules Tuyes , learned he was gay and “committed to charities and activities that raise HIV/AIDS awareness within the New York City gay, *******, bisexual and transsexual Hispanic communities.” When Batista asked his supervisors if they would sponsor Poder Para Todos Unidos (Power for Everyone United), they refused, and Tuyes told Batista that his request had been inappropriate.

The alleged discrimination continued as Tuyes began filing negative reviews “disguised as guidance” regarding Batista’s work flow at Nespresso, as well as an abrupt scheduling change that Batista felt was a “well orchestrated set up.”

A Nespresso spokesperson declined to comment on Batista’s case in a recent story in Edge, but did say, “The company is very concerned that this has come to play,” she said. “We’re saddened anyone would walk away with those feelings and concerns.” They told the Post that they deny the allegations of the complaint, which are still under investigation.

However, the company can’t be too shocked by the complaint, because as Edge reports, “The Nestlé subsidiary’s non-discrimination policy does include gays and lesbians.”

Reply

plecostumus August 12, 2010 at 11:41 pm

I’m an idea person…I am also always tell everyone my ideas. It is only a problem with one particular co-worker, who I learned would take my ideas, then present them in private to our boss and other superiors as her own. It’s not honest. And as a result, I don’t share ideas with her anymore–which is a shame, because she was a smart cookie, and I really liked brainstorming with her. I guess she doesn’t feel confident enough to get ahead on her own merits. I wish I worked in an environment where everyone was open and shared ideas…and we all gave credit when credit was due. Instead, everyone’s just competing against everyone else on the team…and we end up producing less quality work overall.

Reply

zach November 20, 2009 at 11:15 pm

My friend David and I posted these comments to show our support for our Friend Charlie who was ridiculed by James Pergola and Milad Camisi. Charlie worked at Nespresso and was a smart employee and the team leaders treated Charlie and other smart employees badly by exploiting us and other smart employees who work hard. The supervisors at Nespresso take credit for other people’s ideas

Reply

Nespresso Sucks November 19, 2009 at 10:14 pm

The bottom line is that no matter how you react , supervisors always will steal ideas from smart employees who they feel threatene by. I used to work at Nespresso Coffee Club and can honestly my former supervisors Milad Camisi and James Pergola would listen in to the sales calls of their smart employees and they would literally steal the sales ideas of these employees and take credit. Milad Camisi is the definitiona of evil. She would steal all of her employees sales ideas , take credit and then tried to fire these same employees that she stole from.

Reply

Leave a Comment