Sometimes, it becomes clear early on that you can’t count on a new employee. He begins missing work or simply isn’t available when you call him in for extra hours.
Most supervisors who find themselves in that situation will just call a more reliable employee instead. That’s perfectly fine in most cases. Punctuality, reliability and flexibility can and should be rewarded.
Recent case: Gregory Smith, who is black, worked part time as a driver’s helper, but regularly reminded his bosses that he wanted more hours and would like to go full-time. However, his actions said something different altogether. Smith missed lots of work and frequently wasn’t available for additional assignments.
When two white employees got full-time jobs, Smith sued for race discrimination.
But his employer successfully argued that the real reason was Smith’s unreliability. The court said it was appropriate to select from its most reliable workers to fill open positions. (Smith v. Capital Cartage, No. 11-1314, 7th Cir., 2011)
Advice: Never holdor ADA absences against employees when you are making decisions related to job assignments or promotions. Remember that even part-time employees may be eligible for if they have worked the requisite 1,250 hours with at least one year’s service. In addition, disabled employees may be entitled to leave as a reasonable accommodation. Don’t count that time off against them.
- How to Fire an Employee the Legal Way: 6 Termination Guidelines
- OK to treat similar rule violations differently--as long as you document your rationale
- 'Me-too' evidence doesn't prove specific bias
- Dillard's faces age bias charges after firing in Cary
- Was that race discrimination, or just a personality conflict?