• LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Google+

Trouble-free terminations: 5 smart strategies for managers

by on
in Discrimination and Harassment,Employment Law,Firing,HR Management,Management Training,Office Politics,Performance Reviews

Employees will undoubtedly leave their termination meeting in a foul mood. So, don't give them any reason during that meeting to send them marching to a lawyer's office. As you'll see in the case below, one inflammatory phrase from a supervisor can spark a lawsuit.

Get the audio guide to Trouble-Free Terminations when you try The HR Specialist today!
The Right Way to Fire: Briefly deliver the news by summarizing the well-documented, job-related reasons for the termination. That way, while the employee may not like it, he or she will have little to dispute. Allow the person to offer his or her side of the story, even with a little emotion, without interruption.

Also, avoid using any harsh words during termination meetings that would only serve to inflame the issue. Stick to the facts; don't make generalizing statements.

Case in point: During his termination meeting, an employee repeatedly asked why he was being fired. Finally, the employee was told that it was due to his "criminal lifestyle." That phrase angered the employee, causing him to run out and sue for defamation.

The Florida appeals court tossed out the lawsuit, saying that managers who are simply responding to "Why was I fired?" questioning shouldn't be placed on the hook for defamatory claims. (Charles v. State Department of Children and Families)

While the employer in that case won on a legal technicality, it still had to spend big bucks defending the lawsuit in court. The manager could have prevented the lawsuit completely by simply answering the employee with a less caustic, and more job-specific, answer, such as, "Your recent record of convictions gives us reason to doubt your trustworthiness, which is essential for your position."

Trouble-Free Terminations will give you practical, definitive guidance on:
  • How to ensure your written policies support legal firing
  • Ways to effectively track and document performance to support firings
  • Step-by-step protocol for correct firing and classic mistakes to avoid
  • What you must say and do to comply with federal laws
Get it for free when you try HR Specialist now...
Stepping up to the Firing Line: 5 Legally Smart Strategies

1. Avoid surprises. When supervisors document poor performance and give regular feedback, firings shouldn't take anyone by surprise. That will help prevent lawsuits, plus, if the organization ever suffers an employee lawsuit, that documentation can prove to a court that the firing was justified.

2. Keep your cool. Never holler "You're fired!" or berate terminated employees. Remain calm. If employees ask for reasons, stick to concrete, documented productivity facts.

3. Don't be too kind. If an employee's work was substandard, say it. Don't offer compliments to soften the blow. Doing so will only infuriate the employee because it will appear that the firing is without cause, which can spark a wrongful-termination lawsuit.

4. Play by the rules. Follow the organization's established discipline policy, and don't stray from your past practices. Courts will pick apart inconsistencies.

Employers have the right to divert from their discipline policies and fire employees immediately if those employees engage in serious misconduct. But before skipping progressive discipline, verify the facts and discuss the issue with HR. It's not enough to act on rumors of wrongdoing. Employers must conduct a thorough investigation and ask employees for their side.

5. Keep it private and quiet. Discharge employees in closed-door meetings and have HR present. Don't discuss your reasons with other employees. It's enough to say "Elaine will not be working with us anymore." Some supervisors who have spoken too freely about the reasons for a firing have found themselves in court defending a "defamation of character" lawsuit.


Use this 'Memo to Managers' article to educate your supervisors. Paste the content into an e-mail, company newsletter or other communication. Edit as desired.

You'll find 'Memos to Managers' like this in every single issue of the HR Specialist. Subscribe now and you'll also receive these free gifts:


CD coverTrouble-Free Terminations brings back the days when you could fire incompetent employees without concern for discrimination lawsuits or retribution.

book cover

And Difficult People at Work identifies the 24 most common difficult personalities and gives you proven, practical strategies to neutralize their toxic effects.

Get Started Now!

Leave a Comment