Take ‘same race’ bias complaints seriously — Business Management Daily: Free Reports on Human Resources, Employment Law, Office Management, Office Communication, Office Technology and Small Business Tax Business Management Daily

Take ‘same race’ bias complaints seriously

Get PDF file

by on
in Employment Law,Human Resources

Issue: Managers sometimes ignore bias claims when the "discriminator" and the "discriminatee" are from the same protected group.

Risk: Your organization is liable under bias claims regardless of who makes them.

Action: Remind managers to respond to all bias claims. Explain that the "same group" defense won't fly in court.

You wouldn't ignore a black employee's complaint that a white supervisor was discriminating against her, would you? And neither should you ignore a bias complaint from one member of a protected class against another member of that class, as the following cases show.

Recent case No. 1: A black waiter complained after his general manager, a lighter-skinned black man, made offensive comments about the darker color of the waiter's skin. After he threatened to take his complaints to corporate, he was fired. The waiter filed a complaint with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC). The company settled by agreeing to pay the waiter $40,000 and beef up its anti-bias policy and training. (Burch v. Applebee's International Inc., No. 1:02-CV-829)

Recent case No. 2: Shirley Bryant regularly wore a business suit to work, while her boss, also a black woman, often dressed in "Afrocentric" attire.

That style difference led to conflict: The boss accused Bryant of "wanting to be white." When Bryant applied for a transfer, she was fired for insubordination and replaced by a woman with dreadlocks. Bryant sued.

The company argued that federal race-bias laws didn't cover such black-against-black claims. But the court disagreed. (Bryant v. BEGIN Manage Program, E.D.N.Y., 2003)

The lesson: Make sure your anti-bias policy and training specifically ban discrimination because of a person's skin tone. Title VII of the Civil Rights Act not only bans discrimination based on a person's race, but also on the shade of his or her skin.

Note: Such so-called "color discrimination" cases like these are still rare, but they're increasing. The EEOC says color-bias complaints jumped more than 200 percent since the mid-90s (from 413 cases in 1994 to 1,382 in 2002).

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: