Can someone claim they’re so disabled they need Social Security benefits, yet still tell an employer they can perform a job’s essential functions? Sounds fishy, right? A judge thought so.
Recent case: Artist Christine Eck worked for Whirley Industries until she took a lengthy disability leave because of multiple sclerosis. While she was off, she applied for Social Security disability benefits, swearing to the federal agency that she was unable to perform her old job.
Then she told Whirley she was ready to report to work and able to perform all the essential functions of her job. But meanwhile, the company decided to eliminate her position.
Eck sued, alleging ADA discrimination. But the court said she couldn’t have it both ways. (Eck v. Whirley Industries, No. 08-330, WD PA, 2011)
Final note: Had Eck asked for accommodations, she might have had a case.
- How to Fire an Employee the Legal Way: 6 Termination Guidelines
- Investigate to find truth behind discrimination complaints
- Investigate in good faith and your credibility call will stand—even if wrong
- What should we do about email still on former employee's company-issued cellphone?
- Don't pile on reasons for firing; you're spoiling for retaliation fight in court