Under the right circumstances, employers that pay discretionary bonuses based on actual performance don’t have to make the extra payments to employees on. Thus, a discretionary bonus based on performance during each quarter may not have to be paid if the employee didn’t work.
Recent case: Laura Makowski, who worked for a law firm’s marketing department, missed the last quarter of the year because she was pregnant and then gave birth. Ordinarily, she would have earned a quarterly bonus based on performance during that quarter.
She sued when she didn’t receive the bonus and argued she was eligible despite takingleave.
The court disagreed after dissecting the law firm’s bonus program. It determined that she performed no work meriting the bonus during the relevant quarter. (Makowski v. SmithAmundsen, No. 08-CV-6912, ND IL, 2010)
- How to Fire an Employee the Legal Way: 6 Termination Guidelines
- The HR I.Q. Test: April '08
- Incentive pay hours don't count toward the 1,250 hours required for FMLA leave
- First things first on FMLA: Challenge eligibility before approving leave
- When FMLA and ADA could be factors, consider both laws before denying return to work