Question: “I manage a group of four women who bicker constantly and 'cop an attitude.' To make it worse, I recently hired a young, inexperienced secretary who is very rude. When anyone tries to instruct her, she comes back with a smart-mouth response. I feel like I’m supervising a bunch of tattling 2-year-olds. Sometimes, I plan what I’m going to say about these issues, then I chicken out. I know I need a stronger backbone, but I don’t like dealing with conflict. What should I do?” — Tired Supervisor
Marie’s Answer: Having accepted aposition, you must be willing to do management work, which includes resolving . Otherwise, you’re not earning your paycheck.
Get these squabbling children together, tell them you’re tired of the drama, and flatly state that they must start acting like professional adults. They don’t have to like each other, but they do have to be cooperative and civil. This means no bickering, no tattling, no smart-mouth talk.
Their behavior won’t change immediately, so view this as an ongoing project. When you overhear silly quarrels, nip them in the bud.
If your cheeky new secretary continues to mouth off, coach her privately. Provide examples of her ill-mannered comments, then describe more appropriate responses. Meet with her regularly to assess progress.
If you’re too timid for such discussions, you should get out of management. Many kind, caring, sensitive folks fail as managers because they aren’t willing to do the tough stuff.
But here’s the fun part. When you see improvement, reward your group with a staff celebration. If your secretary becomes more tactful, tell her how proud you are. Then quietly pat yourself on the back for having those difficult conversations.
For more tips on managing Ten Steps to an Exceptional Coaching Discussion., see
- 10 Secrets to an Effective Performance Review
- Spot supervisors' hidden bias by monitoring daily stream of info flowing into HR
- Accommodation may mean leave plus reinstatement
- Your dollars at risk: 6 ways to protect yourself from personal liability
- Sudden discipline problems? Check for retaliation by boss